How Diet Affects Horse Behaviour and Temperament
If you've ever fed your horse a new feed and noticed them suddenly acting like a completely different animal — fizzy, spooky, anxious, or just "not themselves" — you're not imagining things. What goes into your horse's feed bucket has a profound effect on how they think, feel, and behave.
The connection between diet and horse behaviour is one of the most important yet frequently overlooked aspects of horse management. While many owners turn to training solutions or supplements when their horse becomes difficult, the answer often lies in what's being fed.
In this article, we'll explore exactly how diet affects horse behaviour and temperament, which feeds and nutrients are the most common culprits, and what practical changes you can make for a calmer, happier horse.
The Science Behind Feed and Behaviour
Horses evolved to spend 16–18 hours a day grazing on low-energy, high-fibre forage. Their digestive systems — and their brains — are designed for a slow, steady trickle of nutrients. When we introduce modern feeds that deliver large amounts of energy in concentrated form, it can create both physical discomfort and behavioural changes.
The key mechanisms linking diet to behaviour include:
- Blood sugar fluctuations — Feeds high in starch and sugar cause rapid spikes and drops in blood glucose, which can trigger excitability, anxiety, and reactivity.
- Gut health disruption — An unhealthy hindgut can cause discomfort, irritability, and even pain-related behaviours like girthiness, bucking, or resistance.
- Nutrient deficiencies or imbalances — Shortfalls in magnesium, B vitamins, or other key nutrients can directly affect the nervous system.
- Excess energy — Simply feeding more calories than your horse needs for their workload is one of the most common causes of "fizzy" or "hot" behaviour.
Starch and Sugar: The Biggest Behavioural Culprits
If there's one dietary factor most closely linked to excitable, unpredictable behaviour in horses, it's the level of non-structural carbohydrates (NSC) — that is, starch and sugar — in the diet.
How Starch Affects Your Horse's Brain
When a horse eats a feed high in starch (such as oats, barley, or a cereal-based mix), the starch is broken down into glucose in the small intestine. This causes a rapid rise in blood sugar, followed by a spike in insulin.
This "sugar rush" doesn't just affect the body — it affects the brain. Research has shown that horses fed high-starch diets are more reactive, more easily startled, and harder to settle than horses fed the same amount of energy from fibre or fat-based sources.
The blood sugar crash that follows can leave horses feeling irritable, restless, or anxious — much like a child after too many sweets.
What Counts as High Starch?
As a general guide:
- Low starch feeds contain less than 10% starch (e.g., fibre-based feeds, unmolassed sugar beet, most chaffs)
- Moderate starch feeds contain 10–20% starch
- High starch feeds contain more than 20% starch (e.g., cereal-based mixes, oats, barley)
For horses prone to behavioural issues, keeping the total diet below 10% NSC is a good target. That includes hay, which can sometimes contain surprisingly high levels of sugar — especially spring and autumn grass.
The Spring Grass Effect
Every spring, riding schools and livery yards around the country report the same phenomenon: previously calm horses suddenly become spooky, tense, or explosive. The reason? Rapidly growing spring grass can contain very high levels of fructans and simple sugars — sometimes exceeding 25% of dry matter.
This is essentially the same mechanism as feeding too much hard feed, but it comes from the pasture rather than the bucket.
Energy Levels: Are You Overfeeding for the Workload?
One of the simplest but most commonly missed causes of "bad" behaviour in horses is overfeeding. A horse that's receiving more energy than they burn will have to put that energy somewhere — and often, it comes out as tension, excitability, napping, or even aggression.
This is particularly common in:
- Good doers on full turnout who also receive hard feed
- Horses in light work being fed a competition-level ration
- Native breeds and cobs fed the same ration as a Thoroughbred in the same yard
Before assuming your horse has a behavioural problem, honestly assess their workload against their calorie intake. Many behaviour issues disappear simply by reducing the feed ration to match actual energy requirements. Analysing your horse's diet is a great first step to understanding whether you're overfeeding — or underfeeding — for your horse's needs.
Fat and Fibre: The Calm Energy Sources
If starch and sugar are the villains in the behaviour story, fibre and fat are the heroes.
Why Fibre Promotes Calm Behaviour
Fibre is fermented slowly in the hindgut, producing volatile fatty acids (VFAs) that provide a slow, sustained release of energy. There are no blood sugar spikes, no insulin surges, and no behavioural rollercoaster.
Fibre-based energy sources include:
- Good quality hay or haylage
- Unmolassed sugar beet
- High-fibre chaffs and cubes
- Soya hulls
A fibre-first approach to feeding is the single most effective dietary strategy for promoting calm, consistent behaviour.
The Role of Dietary Fat
Fat (oil) is an excellent calorie-dense energy source that doesn't affect blood sugar at all. Adding oil to the diet allows you to increase energy intake for horses in harder work without the behavioural side effects of cereals.
Common fat sources include:
- Linseed or linseed oil
- Soya oil
- Rice bran oil
- Feeds with added oil
Research has demonstrated that horses switched from a high-starch diet to a high-fat, high-fibre diet show measurably reduced reactivity and improved trainability — even when the total calorie content remains the same.
Gut Health and Its Effect on Temperament
The equine gut is sometimes called the "second brain," and for good reason. The hindgut contains billions of microorganisms that play a crucial role not just in digestion but in overall health and, increasingly, we understand, in behaviour too.
Hindgut Acidosis
When too much starch bypasses the small intestine and reaches the hindgut (which happens when horses are fed large starch meals), it's rapidly fermented by the wrong type of bacteria. This produces lactic acid, lowers the pH of the hindgut, and kills beneficial fibre-fermenting bacteria.
The result — subclinical hindgut acidosis — causes:
- Discomfort and pain (leading to irritability, girthiness, resistance under saddle)
- Reduced nutrient absorption
- Release of endotoxins into the bloodstream
- Behavioural changes that may look like "attitude" but are actually pain responses
Gastric Ulcers
Gastric ulcers affect an estimated 60–90% of performance horses and are strongly influenced by diet. Horses with ulcers may display:
- Aggression at feed time
- Girthiness and reluctance to be tacked up
- Poor appetite or picky eating
- Resistance, tension, or sudden behavioural changes under saddle
- Teeth grinding
Dietary factors that increase ulcer risk include long periods without forage, high-starch feeds, and insufficient fibre. Ensuring your horse always has access to forage — especially before exercise — is one of the best protective measures.
Key Nutrients That Influence Behaviour
Beyond the big picture of energy sources and gut health, several specific nutrients play direct roles in nervous system function and behaviour.
Magnesium
Magnesium is involved in nerve and muscle function. A genuine magnesium deficiency can cause nervousness, muscle tension, and hypersensitivity. However, it's worth noting that true magnesium deficiency is less common than the supplement industry might suggest. Supplementation is most likely to help if your horse's diet is genuinely deficient — usually when hay or pasture quality is poor.
B Vitamins
B vitamins, particularly B1 (thiamine), play a role in nerve function. Healthy horses typically produce adequate B vitamins through hindgut fermentation, but if gut health is compromised (see above), production may be reduced. Addressing the underlying gut issue is more effective than simply supplementing B vitamins.
Tryptophan
Tryptophan is an amino acid that's a precursor to serotonin, a neurotransmitter associated with calmness and well-being. Some calming supplements contain tryptophan, though evidence for its effectiveness when fed orally to horses is mixed.
Vitamin E and Selenium
These antioxidants support nervous system health. Deficiencies, while relatively uncommon in well-managed horses, can contribute to neuromuscular problems that may manifest as behavioural changes.
Practical Steps to Improve Behaviour Through Diet
If you suspect your horse's diet is contributing to behavioural issues, here's a step-by-step approach:
1. Start With Forage
Ensure your horse has ad-lib or near ad-lib access to good quality forage. This should form the foundation of every horse's diet — typically at least 2% of bodyweight in dry matter per day.
2. Reduce Starch and Sugar
Switch from cereal-based mixes to fibre-and-oil-based feeds. If your horse needs additional energy, add it through oil rather than hard feed.
3. Match Feed to Workload
Be honest about how much work your horse actually does. A horse hacked twice a week does not need a competition feed.
4. Feed Little and Often
If you must feed concentrates, split them into the smallest meals possible. No single meal should contain more than 1–1.5 kg of hard feed for a 500 kg horse.
5. Support Gut Health
Consider a prebiotic or probiotic (yeast-based supplements have the best evidence), ensure constant forage access, and avoid long gaps between meals.
6. Manage Pasture Intake
During high-sugar grass growth periods (spring and autumn, especially sunny mornings after cold nights), consider strip grazing, a grazing muzzle, or limiting turnout hours.
7. Rule Out Pain
Before blaming diet alone, have your vet check for ulcers, dental issues, musculoskeletal pain, and other physical causes of behaviour changes. Diet and pain often work together.
When to Seek Professional Help
If you've made sensible dietary changes and your horse's behaviour hasn't improved after 4–6 weeks, it's time to dig deeper. Consider:
- A veterinary examination to rule out ulcers, pain, or metabolic conditions
- A professional diet review to ensure the overall ration is balanced
- An equine behaviourist if the issue may be learned behaviour rather than diet-related
The Bottom Line
Your horse's behaviour is not separate from their diet — it's a direct reflection of it. The feed bucket is one of the most powerful tools you have for shaping your horse's temperament, reactivity, and willingness to work.
By prioritising fibre, reducing starch and sugar, matching energy to workload, and supporting gut health, you can often achieve more dramatic behavioural improvements than any amount of training or supplementation alone.
The best place to start? Take an honest look at what your horse is actually eating — every mouthful, from hay to hard feed to treats — and ask whether it's truly serving their needs. Small changes to diet can make a remarkable difference to the horse you ride.